Matching Training Volume with Race Expectations

Matching volume to race expectations in the marathon:

When I wrote the first edition of Hansons Marathon Method, I included a few sentences like, ” If you want to run a faster marathon, you need to run more mileage.” I then followed up with something like, “If you can’t, that’s okay; maybe you aren’t ready to run that in the marathon.” Oof, probably could have left that second part out. After a couple of scathing reviews on Amazon, I think I did sneak the delete button over that sentence. 

All this time later, I still feel that way and I think that we are seeing the resurgence of higher volume and in general, I think that is good- when used appropriately. However, I have also had athletes come to me their overall volume was really high for what they were looking to accomplish. We backed them off and within a training segment they crushed a goal they had lost hope in accomplishing. So, that begs the question- what kind of mileage should I really be aiming for to reach my goal? 

Note: Before I dive deep into weekly volumes, let me preface this with a couple of points. First, yes, I know that some people will accomplish a lot more than what I am suggesting off of less average weekly volume. I also know that some people will require a lot more than what I am suggesting. For this discussion, we are referring to what I have seen over my decades of coaching that is an “on average” observation. I’ll try to share some case studies of people I have coached that approached things a little differently. 

The 5+ Hour Crew: 

This can be a tricky group because you have a whole range of experience in runners. You can have anyone whose new to running to those whove run for a long time and this is just where you are. I also see a number of people in this group who have maybe signed up for a marathon as a challenge to lose weight or just get engaged in a fitness or weight loss journey. This can be a tough group to pin down on specifics. It’s also a group you want to tread lightly with because Icertainly don’t discount what they are doing- they are working extremely hard. However, you also want to make sure you give sound advice. 

For this group, I am going to use a current athlete of mine. She came to me way late in the game. I didn’t push too hard on the plan or schedule she was using before but it focused on miles and it wasn’t anywhere near where she needed to be to be ready to run a marathon. This was her first one and her expectations were really high. I just looked at her log and her first run with me was July 8th and she could not cover two miles without walking, or even being able to go much further than that. This is just a little context to the situation. 

I had a few weeks of schedule for her and quickly realized it was way too much for her to tolerate. We scaled back to doing 5-10 minute jogs with small walk breaks and progressing from there. To her absolute credit- she can cover 16 miles! My point with this though I shifted focus from weekly volume in the traditional sense towards time on feet during the week. Ultimately what I would like to see is building weekly volume based on time on feet. In this case, she built several weeks in between 5 and 6 hours, which is about what we expect to finish in. Looking through her log that’s about 30-32 miles per week. So, doing the extrapolation on that, there’d be no way I could expect her to get to 40-45 miles consistently and have any spare time at all. You’re looking at about 10 hours a week of training at that point, which doesn’t include prep time, time for stretching, core, strength, etc. With the volume we got to, we could do that in about four runs per week and she still felt ok to do core and other things during the week. 

4:00-5:00 

I know this is a big range, but the overall volume is about the same here. For me, the minimum is four runs per week, which means you’ll have most runs at over an hour. Throw in a long run and the bare minimum is about 35 miles per week, but would love to see that over 40 and a peak close to 50 miles per week. I say that because at this level, the intensity is going to be mostly moderate for many people and the primary focus is on building endurance. To get to those ideal numbers, you are looking at being 5 days per week. If a person can do that, I feel very comfortable with them reaching a four something goal. If they run less than that, say 3-4 days per week, the primary emphasis has to be on building general endurance and I would also highly recommend doing some type of aerobic based cross training- cycle, elliptical, or zero runner. Incorporating walking if you are a lower mileage person trying to move up to a 5th dayfrom 3-4 days is a great way to begin bridging the gap. But, for the sake of this discussion I would say minimum of 4 days a week and about 35 miles/week on average with emphasis on building endurance over intensity. As you get closer to 4 hours, I would say you will need to be closer to the higher end of my recommended volume and runs. If not, heavily incorporating appropriate cross training. 

3:30 to Sub 4 

I have talked about this in the past, but I feel like 4 hours is the point where training intnesities really hit what I would describe as “textbook definitions.” To be in this goal range we really start focusing on the whole aspect of training. Here, we are looking at 5-6 days per week and I would love to see an average of 40-45 miles per week, with peak volume at 45-50. 

3:00-3:30

Once you are getting down in this range, most people are 5+ days per week, but given that, this is probably the group that seems to be more susceptible to overdoing the weekly volume. Those in the 3:15-3:30 range can often do well with similar weekly volume as the group we just discussed. It really comes down to cosnsitency and health with these runners. However, what I will see is these runners get down to 3:20 (or whatever the case is) and naturally keep progressing volume and they plateau out. I’ve backed a lot of people down in this range from 55-60 miles a week down to 50 miles a week and they would break through their plateau. 

Those closer to 3:00, are usually in that 60+ miles per week range. This is pretty universal for men and women. I get countless reports yearly from people using the advanced HMM plan to get in this range. 

Sub 3 

For the vast majority of athletes I have had run sub 3, they have all had average weeks of 55-60 miles per week and peaks of 65-70. I am aware of many people who run low to mid 2:50’s off the Advanced HMM plan, but do tend to be younger (20’s to early 30’s). Overall, this group does tolerate more miles, but they are also seemingly better at things like strength training and mobility than the majority of people in the other groups. I will see a fair number of people on the cusp of this group simply want to add more volume, but I would encourage them to add the areas like strength, mobility, better recovery first. Then start adding more volume. I think many of these folks want to get to 80+ miles a week before maxing out what they can do at 65.

Sub 2:45

To me, this where things start to get exponentially harder to shave small amounts of time off. At this level, be looking for average weekly mileage in the 70+ range and peak weeks in the 80’s. 

The hard part about once you get past this point is that you really have to find that balance between keeping marriages intact, your job, and attending your kids games. We could prob get them to more mileage, but most of the athletes I work with don’t have the luxury and so we work within the time constraints of, you know, the real world.

To close, I think your big takeaway should be to maximize what you are doing at a mileage level before just jumping to a new level. If you only did one marathon segment at 40 miles a week on average, there isn’t a need to just up the ante on the mileage. Keep improving where you are at and then start adding the volume. Not only can you become much better without undue added training g stress, you can make smaller adjustments upward (when you do increase) and see more improvements longer. So take this as a guide, but as I lead with, it’s not going to line up with every single person. 

 

Sign Up for Updates & Free Resources!

Related Articles